A Report on Brexit and youth work in Scotland

A report released today by two leading youth work sector organisations shows youth workers have witnessed a negative impact on community relations since the EU Referendum in June 2016.

Thumbnail for HEAR.EU Report

Over 50% of those who responded to the survey reported a variety of impact including: young people feeling excluded from democracy, emboldened intolerance on social media, divided communities, and a loss of public trust in information.

YouthLink Scotland and Youth Scotland have collaborated to explore the impact of Brexit on the youth work sector in Scotland and to support youth workers in their work with young people on Brexit. This project and this report is called Hear.EU.

The findings also show that youth work practitioners did not feel informed about Brexit, and the majority of respondents were unsure of the financial impact on the sector, although their perception of future funding was broadly understood to be negative.

Key findings

Commenting on the findings of the report, Tim Frew, Chief Executive of YouthLink Scotland said:

“It is clear that as we approach the final deadline for Brexit, there is considerable unease across society about the impact of leaving the EU, and that includes Scotland’s youth work sector. We know that many Scottish young people have felt disenfranchised through the process of the EU referendum and in the events that have followed. At the very heart of youth work is the voice of young people, it is essential to ensure that young people can realise their rights, be able to participate fully in our democracy and have a voice in the decisions that may affect their future. We will be working alongside the sector to secure sustainable investment in youth work and to explore the place of youth voice and political literacy within the next National Youth Work Strategy.”

Ian McLaughlan, Chief Executive of Youth Scotland said:

“We know through our members that young people and youth workers are passionate about living in a positive, caring and fair country. Our work across the 5 nations with the British Irish Parliamentary Assembly and wider projects have consistently shown this. At its heart, youth work is about empowering young people in our communities and enabling them to form and express views on their democratic rights and participate as active citizens. However, through this research it is clear that youth workers are seeing the impact which Brexit is having on many young people in their communities, with a lack of engagement in the process and lack of information leading to feelings of disempowerment. As we move forward, it is vital that youth workers across Scotland are well equipped and resourced to engage young people and make a positive difference in the communities that they are an integral part of—now and in the future.”

Constitutional Relations Secretary Michael Russell said:

“It’s been really important throughout this divisive and disruptive Brexit process for people across Scotland to have their voices heard. YouthLink Scotland’s workshops have engaged youth workers, children and young people across the country and their work has helped to inform my ongoing discussions with the UK Government and other devolved administrations. The Scottish Government is committed to proactively publishing information on the potential impacts of Brexit on youth work, and will continue to listen to young people about the UK leaving the EU.”

Following publication of this report, YouthLink Scotland and Youth Scotland will take the following steps to support the sector:

Responding to the findings of the report, Dave Beck, Lecturer in Community Development, University of Glasgow commented:

“Youth Work has never been more needed than it is now. Brexit highlights a society which is polarised, politics which is reduced to slogans and sound bites and a citizenry which stands by bewildered and disconnected. Youth Work is needed to help rebuild a vibrant, participatory democracy where there are spaces to think, challenge and hold all accountable for shaping our collective future.”

“I think young people are disillusioned by Brexit; the constant, and conflicting, media coverage and the fact that it’s still ongoing… I’m not sure if Brexit is a good example of democracy – young people were not able to vote in the EU referendum and so I’m not surprised that they feel frustrated and/or disengaged from it all.” (Youth Worker, Survey)

“European communities perhaps feeling more ostracised. Relationships between Scotland and the rest of UK have been more strained.”  (Youth Worker,Workshop)

“I don’t think in my area there has been an increase in racism…I think young people are at risk or being apathetic and disillusioned by the process.” (Youth Worker, Workshop)

Youth work in Scotland reaches 380,000 young people each week. The youth work sector workforce is comprised of 80,000 practitioners, of whom 70,000 are volunteers.

168 youth work practitioners working and volunteering across Scotland were asked about their views through a combination of workshops and an online survey between December 2018 and January 2019.

YouthLink Scotland, the national agency for youth work, and Youth Scotland, the network for community based youth work, were funded by the Scottish Government Brexit Stakeholder Engagement Fund to conduct research on Brexit with the youth work sector in Scotland.